Suspects charged with murder in Pinyon Pines case

Robert Pape could face death penalty

Suspects charged with murder

INDIO, Calif. - Two men accused in the Pinyon Pines triple murder case appeared in a Riverside courtroom Wednesday morning.  KESQ & CBS Local 2 were the only television outlets in the courtroom, where just before 10:30 a.m., a Grand Jury indictment was unsealed.

Robert Pape and Cristin Smith have been charged with three counts of murder for the deaths of 18-year old Rebecca Friedli, her mother Vickie Friedli, 53, and her mother's boyfriend, 55-year-old Jon Hayward. The three victims were killed in their Pinyon Pines home in September, 2006.

More Information

Due to Smith only being 17 at the time of the murders, his name was officially stricken from the Grand Jury indictment, but he was still charged with murder by the District Attorney's office.

Pape, who was 18 at the time of the murders, could now face the death penalty because of an added enhancement charge of committing multiple murders, and also some additional weapons charges.

Smith plead not guilty because he had an attorney present at Wednesday's hearing.  Pape was represented by a public defender and did not enter a plea, he is seeking private representation.  

Both men were arrested Tuesday; Smith at the Palm Springs Airport, Pape at a home in Salton City. 

They're currently being held without bail at the Robert Presley Detention Center in Riverside.

Their next court appearance is scheduled for March, 18, at the Larson Justice Center in Indio. Pape will officially be arraigned and Smith will appear for a felony settlement hearing.


comments powered by Disqus

Photo Galleries

  • On this day: October 26
    Tilla/Wikimedia Commons

    On this day: October 26

    The Erie Canal opens, the Pony Express closes, Wyatt Earp shoots it out in Tombstone, and the Patriot Act is signed into law, all on this day.

    Read More »
  • States with most and least powerful voters
    iStock / bns124

    States with most and least powerful voters

    With the presidential election rapidly approaching, WalletHub has released its list of the states with the most and least powerful voters. Click through to see where your state ranks.

    Read More »
  • Changes since last Cubs' World Series
    Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

    Changes since last Cubs' World Series

    The Chicago Cubs are back in the World Series for the first time since 1945. See how times have changed over the past 71 years.

    Read More »
  • The many looks of Katy Perry
    Jason Merritt/Getty Images

    The many looks of Katy Perry

    Pop singer Katy Perry has made a big impact on the music scene in the few years she has been around. In celebration of her 32nd birthday on Tuesday, join us for a look at her career so far.

    Read More »
  • On this day: October 25
    Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

    On this day: October 25

    Pablo Picasso is born, the first domestic microwave oven goes on sale, Led Zeppelin debuts in concert, the U.S. invades Grenada, and Bill Buckner blows it for the Red Sox, all on this day.

    Read More »